Homes for Sale in Spencer
“Discover your next home in Spencer”
Spencer Real Estate at a Glance
Current market statistics for Spencer, IN
41
Active Listings
$349K
Avg Price
$270K
Median Price
2,157
Avg Sqft
135
Avg Days
Price Range
From
$17,250
To
$2,499,999
Editor's Picks
Our curated selection of the finest spencer homes
More Spencer Homes
More standout listings from across the Spencer market
$425K
981 Denali Drive
Spencer, IN
$375K
45 Flatwoods Road
Spencer, IN
$320K
4304 Newport Road
Spencer, IN
$200K
205 N Main Street
Spencer, IN
$425K
981 Denali Drive
Spencer, IN
$375K
45 Flatwoods Road
Spencer, IN
$250K
502 W Hillside Avenue
Spencer, IN
$220K
427 E Jefferson Street
Spencer, IN
Homes for Sale in Spencer
Every active listing in Spencer, browsable page by page.
$200K
3504 Hardscrabble Road
Spencer, IN
$595K
2919 Schooling Road
Spencer, IN
$259K
982 E Porter Ridge Road
Spencer, IN
$315K
18 Lindsay Court
Spencer, IN
$250K
502 W Hillside Avenue
Spencer, IN
$180K
1198 N Us Highway 231
Spencer, IN
$599K
2636 Country Club Road
Spencer, IN
$110K
“896 Sq Ft 2 Bed 2 Bath 1984 Mobile Home on 3 Acres with Barn in Spencer, IN”
3149 Horse Farm Drive
Spencer, IN
$100K
561 Rocky Hill Road
Spencer, IN
$296K
3103 Freedom Road
Spencer, IN
$549K
806 Texas Pike
Spencer, IN
$387K
1845 S US Hwy 231 Highway
Spencer, IN
$200K
3722 Megan Court
Spencer, IN
$320K
4304 Newport Road
Spencer, IN
$340K
2306 Rattlesnake Road
Spencer, IN
$260K
1650 E State Road 46 Road
Spencer, IN
$360K
750 Clark Road
Spencer, IN
$220K
427 E Jefferson Street
Spencer, IN
$255K
168 E North Street
Spencer, IN
$425K
981 Denali Drive
Spencer, IN
$425K
981 Denali Drive
Spencer, IN
$389K
310 Garden Park Place
Spencer, IN
$340K
69 S Main Street
Spencer, IN
$270K
3331 Westward Road
Spencer, IN
$230K
767 N Laymon Avenue
Spencer, IN
$230K
767 Laymon Avenue
Spencer, IN
$90K
00 Concord Road
Spencer, IN
$740K
9483 W Fenceline Road
Spencer, IN
$115K
1120 Cedar Lane
Spencer, IN
$650K
168 N Harrison Street
Spencer, IN
$2.5M
2034 Dubois Road
Spencer, IN
$260K
1650 E State Road 46
Spencer, IN
$50K
3402 W Moore Road
Spencer, IN
$200K
205 N Main Street
Spencer, IN
$349K
9677 W Reeves Road
Spencer, IN
$35K
732 W Thornridge Way
Spencer, IN
$17K
“1.35 Acre Building Lot on Amazon Shores in Spencer, IN with Lake Access”
00 Lakeside Drive
Spencer, IN
$17K
“Wooded 1.17 Acre Building Site with Electric and Lake Access in Spencer, IN”
00 Estes Road
Spencer, IN
$375K
45 Flatwoods Road
Spencer, IN
$375K
45 Flatwoods Road
Spencer, IN
$449K
“1900 Commercial Office Building 23 S Main Street Spencer IN with 4 Offices”
23 S Main Street
Spencer, IN
Showing 1–41 of 41 · Page 1 of 1
Continue exploring Spencer
Turn the listings into a short list with a clearer read on the Spencer market, its neighborhoods, and the home features that matter to you.
Spencer Housing Market
Spencer, Indiana has 41 homes for sale, with a median list price of $269,900. Browse active listings, filter by price, beds, and property type, and compare homes across the Spencer market.
Median list price $269,900 · Range $17,250–$2,499,999 · 41 active listings
Frequently Asked Questions
How many homes are for sale in Spencer, Indiana?
What is the average home price in Spencer, Indiana?
What is the median home price in Spencer?
How long do homes stay on the market in Spencer?
Shape your search
Browse Spencer by home feature
Ready to make the list yours?
Use the full search to set your price, beds, property type, and must-have features for Spencer.