Michigan

Homes for Sale in Suttons Bay

“Discover your next home in Suttons Bay”

57 listings

Avg $1,040,979

124 days avg

Search All 57 Homes

Explore

Market Overview

Suttons Bay Real Estate at a Glance

Current market statistics for Suttons Bay, MI

Active Listings

$1.0M

Avg Price

$750K

Median Price

3,311

Avg Sqft

124

Avg Days

Price Range

From

$37,500

$5,400,000

Handpicked

Editor's Picks

Our curated selection of the finest suttons bay homes

$1.6M

1476 Brencris Lane

Suttons Bay, MI

$1.1M

470 S Donnybrook Road

Suttons Bay, MI

$925K

2567 N Evergreen Valley Drive

Suttons Bay, MI

$735K

1474 S Montmorency Lane

$1.6M

10112 E John Michael Drive

Featured

More Suttons Bay Homes

More standout listings from across the Suttons Bay market

Single Family

$1.6M

1476 Brencris Lane

Suttons Bay, MI

6 bd3 ba3,830

Single Family

$1.1M

470 S Donnybrook Road

Suttons Bay, MI

3 bd3 ba2,800

Single Family

$925K

2567 N Evergreen Valley Drive

Suttons Bay, MI

3 bd3 ba3,699

Single Family

$735K

1474 S Montmorency Lane

Suttons Bay, MI

5 bd4 ba4,166

Single Family

$1.6M

10112 E John Michael Drive

Suttons Bay, MI

4 bd3 ba3,351

Condo

$995K

750 N Waypoint Circle

Suttons Bay, MI

3 bd3 ba2,493

Single Family

$950K

6261 S Westwood Pkwy

Suttons Bay, MI

5 bd3 ba3,676

Single Family

$589K

12166 E Old Orchard Trail

Suttons Bay, MI

3 bd3 ba2,648

Browse

Homes for Sale in Suttons Bay

Every active listing in Suttons Bay, browsable page by page.

Single Family

$2.3M

10702 E Hilltop Road

Suttons Bay, MI

2 bd2 ba1,757

Commercial

$2.3M

10702 E Hilltop Road

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba1,757

Single Family

$1.6M

10112 E John Michael Drive

Suttons Bay, MI

4 bd3 ba3,351

Land

$60K

1909 N Blue Water Court

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba

Single Family

$890K

10953 E Pobuda Road

Suttons Bay, MI

3 bd3 ba2,134

Single Family

$1.6M

1476 Brencris Lane

Suttons Bay, MI

6 bd3 ba3,830

Single Family

$589K

12166 E Old Orchard Trail

Suttons Bay, MI

3 bd3 ba2,648

Single Family

$320K

10510 E Shady Lane

Suttons Bay, MI

3 bd2 ba1,154

Single Family

$2.6M

737 S Stony Point Road

Suttons Bay, MI

4 bd2 ba2,287

Single Family

$900K

800 N St Joseph Street

Suttons Bay, MI

3 bd1 ba1,200

Single Family

$950K

6261 S Westwood Pkwy

Suttons Bay, MI

5 bd3 ba3,676

Single Family

$1.4M

488 S Stony Point Road

Suttons Bay, MI

2 bd1 ba1,662

Single Family

$485K

5910 S Cummings

Suttons Bay, MI

3 bd2 ba1,176

Condo

$475K

11255 E Fort Road

Suttons Bay, MI

3 bd2 ba1,244

Single Family

$665K

151 S Crestwood Drive

Suttons Bay, MI

4 bd2 ba1,914

Single Family

$1.9M

3784 S Lee Point Road

Suttons Bay, MI

2 bd2 ba1,337

Single Family

$1.2M

2768 S Center Highway

Suttons Bay, MI

2 bd2 ba1,836

Condo

$1.3M

704 N Dockside Circle

Suttons Bay, MI

4 bd3 ba2,275

Land

$350K

0 E Smiseth Road

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba

Land

$149K

112 W Madison Avenue

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba

Condo

$995K

750 N Waypoint Circle

Suttons Bay, MI

3 bd3 ba2,493

Single Family

$1.1M

470 S Donnybrook Road

Suttons Bay, MI

3 bd3 ba2,800

Land

$950K

0 M-22

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba

Condo

$750K

760 Waypoint Circle

Suttons Bay, MI

3 bd2 ba2,493

Condo

$750K

758 Waypoint Circle

Suttons Bay, MI

3 bd2 ba2,493

Land

$75K

00 E Sugar Maple Court

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba

Single Family

$925K

2567 N Evergreen Valley Drive

Suttons Bay, MI

3 bd3 ba3,699

Land

$38K

1955 N Blue Water Court

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba

Land

$42K

1949 N Blue Water Court

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba

Land

$79K

1912 N Blue Water Court

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba

Condo

$1.1M

764 N Waypoint Circle

Suttons Bay, MI

3 bd3 ba2,493

Land

$89K

2155 N Belanger Creek Drive

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba

Land

$140K

2164 N Belanger Creek Drive

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba

Land

$199K

2171 N Belanger Creek Drive

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba

Land

$199K

1881 N Blue Water Court

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba

Single Family

$735K

1474 S Montmorency Lane

Suttons Bay, MI

5 bd4 ba4,166

Condo

$1.2M

766 N Waypoint Circle

Suttons Bay, MI

3 bd2 ba2,493

Condo

$799K

762 N Waypoint Circle

Suttons Bay, MI

3 bd2 ba2,493

Commercial

$3.0M

5046 S West Bay Shore

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd11 ba18,000

Commercial

$199K

“4.30 Acre Commercial Vacant Land on M-22 Suttons Bay Michigan”

5046 S West Bay Shore Drive

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba

Commercial

$1.4M

5046 S West Bay Shore

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba8,702

Commercial

$199K

“4.30-Acre Commercial Vacant Land on M-22 in Suttons Bay, MI”

5046 S West Bay Shore Drive

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba

Land

$199K

“4.30 Acre Waterfront Land on M-22 with Development Potential in Suttons Bay MI”

5046 S West Bay Shore Drive

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba

Land

$199K

“4.30 Acre Waterfront Vacant Land on M-22, Suttons Bay, MI”

5046 S West Bay Shore Drive

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba

Single Family

$1.1M

9224 E Duck Lake Road

Suttons Bay, MI

4 bd1 ba1,783

Commercial

$5.4M

9224 E Duck Lake Road

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba1,783

Land

$60K

1909 N Blue Water Court

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba

Commercial

$699K

5046 S West Bay Shore

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba2,751

Commercial

$799K

1375 West Bay Shore Drive

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba3,187

Commercial

$900K

5046 S West Bay Shore

Suttons Bay, MI

0 bd0 ba4,032

Showing 1–50 of 57 · Page 1 of 2

Beyond the listings

Continue exploring Suttons Bay

Turn the listings into a short list with a clearer read on the Suttons Bay market, its neighborhoods, and the home features that matter to you.

Refine Suttons Bay search All Michigan homes

Local market guide

Suttons Bay Housing Market

Suttons Bay, Michigan has 57 homes for sale, with a median list price of $750,000. Browse active listings, filter by price, beds, and property type, and compare homes across the Suttons Bay market.

Median list price $750,000 · Range $37,500–$5,400,000 · 57 active listings

Buyer questions

Frequently Asked Questions

How many homes are for sale in Suttons Bay, Michigan?

There are currently 57 homes for sale in Suttons Bay, MI as of September 2026.

What is the average home price in Suttons Bay, Michigan?

The average home price in Suttons Bay is $1,040,979. Prices range from $37,500 to $5,400,000.

What is the median home price in Suttons Bay?

The median home price in Suttons Bay, MI is $750,000, which represents the middle price point of all listings.

How long do homes stay on the market in Suttons Bay?

Homes in Suttons Bay spend an average of 124 days on the market before going under contract.

Shape your search

Browse Suttons Bay by home feature

Solar Homes EV-Ready Homes Pool Homes Waterfront Homes Homes with Views Price Reduced Homes New Listings This Week New Construction Homes

Nationwide collections

Explore by lifestyle

Beach LivingWaterfront Homes Mountain RetreatsElevated Living Investment PropertiesIncome-Generating Real Estate Family FriendlyRoom to Grow Luxury EstatesExceptional Living Modern DesignContemporary Architecture

Ready to make the list yours?

Use the full search to set your price, beds, property type, and must-have features for Suttons Bay.

Search Suttons Bay homes