Homes for Sale in Jay
“38 active listings in Jay, New York · Average list price $327,466”
Jay Real Estate at a Glance
Current market statistics for Jay, NY
38
Active Listings
$327K
Avg Price
$275
Price/Sqft
238
Avg Days
Price Range
From
$21,000
To
$995,000
Property Types
Nearby Cities
Explore homes for sale in cities near Jay, New York
Homes to Explore
Active listings from the jay collection
More from Jay
More active listings from across the Jay market
$70K
7 Covered Bridge Ln
Jay, NY
$275K
6653 New York 86
Jay, NY
$395K
163 Stickney Bridge Road
Jay, NY
$380K
73 Forest Lane
Jay, NY
$525K
97 Danielle Road
Jay, NY
$495K
29 Algonquin Lane
Jay, NY
$659K
93 Beech Street
Jay, NY
$675K
183 Ridge Top Lane
Jay, NY
Homes for Sale in Jay
Every active listing in Jay, browsable page by page.
$30K
Evergreen Lane
Jay, NY
$449K
51 Hochsteig Lane
Jay, NY
$525K
97 Danielle Road
Jay, NY
$539K
29 Antler Drive
Jay, NY
$675K
183 Ridge Top Lane
Jay, NY
$275K
6653 New York 86
Jay, NY
$565K
88 Scenic Point Lane
Jay, NY
$380K
73 Forest Lane
Jay, NY
$70K
7 Covered Bridge Ln
Jay, NY
$495K
29 Algonquin Lane
Jay, NY
$749K
561 Hazen Road
Jay, NY
$375K
2 Butternut Lane
Jay, NY
$478K
30 Hawthorne Lane
Jay, NY
$30K
Tannenbaum Lane lot: 119
Jay, NY
$395K
163 Stickney Bridge Road
Jay, NY
$30K
Tannenbaum Lane lot: 118
Jay, NY
$995K
6487 NYS Rt 86
Jay, NY
$29K
38 Algonquin Lane
Jay, NY
$359K
18 Elm Street
Jay, NY
$319K
84 Sawmill Drive
Jay, NY
$85K
Crowningshield Way (Lot #3)
Jay, NY
$169K
369 Upper Jay-Trumbulls Corners Road
Jay, NY
$29K
Dogwood Street
Jay, NY
$26K
Sequoia Mountain Lane
Jay, NY
$255K
22 Fawn Lane
Jay, NY
$105K
109 Ridge Top Road
Jay, NY
$659K
93 Beech Street
Jay, NY
$375K
26 Summit Lane
Jay, NY
$595K
205 River Road
Jay, NY
$770K
32 Seneca Trail
Jay, NY
$160K
571 Stickney Bridge Road
Jay, NY
$185K
67 Alder St.
Jay, NY
$259K
Wildernesscapes Way lot: 2
Jay, NY
$21K
186 lot Spruce Lane
Jay, NY
$53K
NYS Route 9N
Jay, NY
$235K
64 Beech Street
Jay, NY
$675K
183 Ridge Top Lane
Jay, NY
Showing 1–37 of 38 · Page 1 of 1
Continue exploring Jay
Turn the listings into a short list with a clearer read on the Jay market, its neighborhoods, and the home features that matter to you.
Jay Housing Market
Browse 38 active listings in Jay, New York. The average list price for this active inventory is $327,466. Compare the price and property details reported in each listing.
Average list price $327,466 · Range $21,000–$995,000 · 38 active listings
Frequently Asked Questions
How many active listings are available in Jay, New York?
What is the average list price in Jay, New York?
What is the average days on market for active listings in Jay?
What is the average list price per square foot in Jay?
Shape your search
Browse Jay by home feature
Nationwide collections
Explore by listing details
Ready to make the list yours?
Use the full search to set your price, beds, property type, and must-have features for Jay.