New York

Homes for Sale in Water Mill

“40 active listings in Water Mill, New York · Average list price $12,559,475”

40 listings

Avg $12,559,475

270 days avg

Search All 40 Homes

Explore

Market Overview

Water Mill Real Estate at a Glance

Current market statistics for Water Mill, NY

Active Listings

$12.6M

Avg Price

$1407

Price/Sqft

270

Avg Days

Price Range

From

$595,000

$82,500,000

Property Types

Other

Single Family

Nearby Cities

Explore homes for sale in cities near Water Mill, New York

Westhampton Beach, NY

Listing selection

Homes to Explore

Active listings from the water mill collection

$2.9M

172 Mill Pond Lane

Water Mill, NY

$2.5M

288 Water Mill Towd Road

Water Mill, NY

$7.0M

1627 DEERFIELD RD

Water Mill, NY

$6.5M

69 Swans Neck

$9.9M

560 Little Noyac Path

More listings

Homes for Sale in Water Mill

Every active listing in Water Mill, browsable page by page.

Single Family

$3.0M

2 Schwenks Road

Water Mill, NY

4 bd5 ba2,400

Single Family

$2.5M

288 Water Mill Towd Road

Water Mill, NY

4 bd4 ba3,014

Single Family

$2.0M

7 WOODY CT

Water Mill, NY

4 bd4 ba2,728

Single Family

$3.8M

719 Little Noyac Path

Water Mill, NY

4 bd4 ba4,500

Commercial

$595K

760 Montauk HWY

Water Mill, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Commercial

$29.5M

231 Montauk

Water Mill, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Single Family

$9.9M

560 Little Noyac Path

Water Mill, NY

8 bd10 ba9,831

Single Family

$6.5M

69 Swans Neck

Water Mill, NY

5 bd4 ba5,161

Single Family

$9.9M

560 Little Noyac Path

Water Mill, NY

8 bd10 ba9,857

Single Family

$3.0M

4 Trail Court

Water Mill, NY

4 bd5 ba1,720

Single Family

$8.0M

165 Strongs Lane

Water Mill, NY

7 bd9 ba8,200

Single Family

$8.5M

15 Little Cobb Road

Water Mill, NY

4 bd3 ba3,059

Single Family

$7.0M

1627 DEERFIELD RD

Water Mill, NY

6 bd9 ba11,888

Land

$4.5M

1004 Montauk Highway

Water Mill, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Single Family

$4.5M

14 Wood Edge Court

Water Mill, NY

3 bd3 ba3,170

Single Family

$10.8M

37 TIFFANY WAY

Water Mill, NY

7 bd9 ba8,142

Single Family

$13.0M

112 Cobb

Water Mill, NY

8 bd11 ba8,020

Single Family

$12.5M

1344 Deerfield

Water Mill, NY

7 bd8 ba0

Single Family

$16.0M

460 Edge Of Woods Road

Water Mill, NY

8 bd12 ba9,906

Single Family

$2.6M

165 Roses Grove Road

Water Mill, NY

3 bd4 ba1,500

Single Family

$12.0M

450 Seven Ponds Towd Road

Water Mill, NY

8 bd12 ba9,906

Single Family

$4.7M

532 Blank Lane

Water Mill, NY

4 bd5 ba3,500

Single Family

$10.8M

170 Scuttle Hole Road

Water Mill, NY

7 bd9 ba10,000

Single Family

$4.2M

109 SEVEN PONDS RD

Water Mill, NY

5 bd4 ba3,600

Single Family

$1.8M

54 Hayground Road

Water Mill, NY

4 bd3 ba2,400

Land

$5.0M

731 Deerfield (Lot #4) Road

Water Mill, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Commercial

$595K

760 Montauk Highway

Water Mill, NY

0 bd1 ba1,880

Single Family

$5.5M

1366 Scuttle Hole Road

Water Mill, NY

5 bd6 ba4,631

Single Family

$2.9M

172 Mill Pond Lane

Water Mill, NY

4 bd5 ba3,500

Single Family

$10.0M

1552 Deerfield Road

Water Mill, NY

8 bd12 ba9,400

Single Family

$2.6M

30 Lower Seven Ponds Road

Water Mill, NY

5 bd4 ba1,915

Single Family

$2.3M

112 Upper 7 Ponds Road

Water Mill, NY

4 bd3 ba2,134

Single Family

$25M

54 Jule Pond Drive

Water Mill, NY

6 bd8 ba7,500

Single Family

$10.0M

158 Cobb Road

Water Mill, NY

7 bd9 ba9,600

Single Family

$7.0M

89 Cobb Road

Water Mill, NY

4 bd5 ba3,000

Single Family

$82.5M

70 & 71 Cobb Lane

Water Mill, NY

24 bd38 ba45,000

Single Family

$42.5M

70 Cobb Lane

Water Mill, NY

11 bd19 ba28,000

Single Family

$40.0M

71 Cobb Lane

Water Mill, NY

13 bd19 ba17,173

Showing 1–38 of 40 · Page 1 of 1

Beyond the listings

Continue exploring Water Mill

Turn the listings into a short list with a clearer read on the Water Mill market, its neighborhoods, and the home features that matter to you.

Refine Water Mill search All New York homes

Local market guide

Water Mill Housing Market

Browse 40 active listings in Water Mill, New York. The average list price for this active inventory is $12,559,475. Compare the price and property details reported in each listing.

Average list price $12,559,475 · Range $595,000–$82,500,000 · 40 active listings

Buyer questions

Frequently Asked Questions

How many active listings are available in Water Mill, New York?

The current inventory contains 40 active listings in Water Mill, NY.

What is the average list price in Water Mill, New York?

The average list price among current active listings in Water Mill, NY is $12,559,475. Current list prices range from $595,000 to $82,500,000.

What is the average days on market for active listings in Water Mill?

Current active listings in Water Mill, NY report an average of 270 days on market.

What is the average list price per square foot in Water Mill?

The average list price per square foot among current active listings in Water Mill, NY is $1407.

Shape your search

Browse Water Mill by home feature

Homes with Solar Features Homes with EV Chargers Homes with Pools Waterfront Homes Homes with Views Homes with Recorded Price Reductions Listings Added to PropertySimple in the Past 7 Days Homes Built Since 2024

Nationwide collections

Explore by listing details

Waterfront ListingsListings Marked Waterfront Listings in Mountain StatesSix-State Collection Multi-Family & Commercial ListingsListings by Property Type Listings with 3+ BedroomsThree or More Bedrooms Listings Priced at $1.5M+Listings by Asking Price Listings Built Since 2015Listings by Year Built

Ready to make the list yours?

Use the full search to set your price, beds, property type, and must-have features for Water Mill.

Search Water Mill homes

Homes for Sale in Water Mill

Water Mill Real Estate at a Glance

Price Range

Property Types

Nearby Cities

Homes to Explore

More from Water Mill

172 Mill Pond Lane

288 Water Mill Towd Road

1627 DEERFIELD RD

69 Swans Neck

560 Little Noyac Path

560 Little Noyac Path

71 Cobb Lane

170 Scuttle Hole Road

Homes for Sale in Water Mill

2 Schwenks Road

288 Water Mill Towd Road

7 WOODY CT

719 Little Noyac Path

760 Montauk HWY

231 Montauk

560 Little Noyac Path

69 Swans Neck

560 Little Noyac Path

4 Trail Court

165 Strongs Lane

15 Little Cobb Road

1627 DEERFIELD RD

1004 Montauk Highway

14 Wood Edge Court

37 TIFFANY WAY

112 Cobb

1344 Deerfield

460 Edge Of Woods Road

165 Roses Grove Road

450 Seven Ponds Towd Road

532 Blank Lane

170 Scuttle Hole Road

109 SEVEN PONDS RD

54 Hayground Road

731 Deerfield (Lot #4) Road

760 Montauk Highway

1366 Scuttle Hole Road

172 Mill Pond Lane

1552 Deerfield Road

30 Lower Seven Ponds Road

112 Upper 7 Ponds Road

54 Jule Pond Drive

158 Cobb Road

89 Cobb Road

70 & 71 Cobb Lane

70 Cobb Lane

71 Cobb Lane

Water Mill Housing Market

Frequently Asked Questions

How many active listings are available in Water Mill, New York?

What is the average list price in Water Mill, New York?

What is the average days on market for active listings in Water Mill?

What is the average list price per square foot in Water Mill?

Browse Water Mill by home feature

Explore by listing details

Ready to make the list yours?