Skip to main content
Homes for sale in Sister Bay, Wisconsin
Wisconsin

Homes for Sale in Sister Bay

“80 active listings in Sister Bay, Wisconsin · Average list price $640,992”

80 listings
Avg $640,992
137 days avg
Search All 80 Homes
Explore
Market Overview

Sister Bay Real Estate at a Glance

Current market statistics for Sister Bay, WI

80

Active Listings

$641K

Avg Price

$648

Price/Sqft

137

Avg Days

Price Range

From

$48,000

To

$4,950,000

Property Types

Other

72

Condo

4

Single Family

4

Nearby Cities

Explore homes for sale in cities near Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Egg Harbor, WI
94 homes for sale
Within 25 mi
Sturgeon Bay, WI
57 homes for sale
Within 25 mi
Fish Creek, WI
46 homes for sale
Within 25 mi
Ellison Bay, WI
24 homes for sale
Within 25 mi
Ephraim, WI
15 homes for sale
Within 25 mi
Baileys Harbor, WI
14 homes for sale
Within 25 mi
Crivitz, WI
21 homes for sale
Within 60 mi
Abrams, WI
17 homes for sale
Within 60 mi
Listing selection

Homes to Explore

Active listings from the sister bay collection

10712 Timber Ridge Cr, Sister Bay, WI - $369K

$369K

10712 Timber Ridge Cr

Sister Bay, WI

10570 BAY RIDGE Place - Condo for sale in Sister Bay, WI

$369K

10570 BAY RIDGE Place

Sister Bay, WI

2294 Hill Rd - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI

$541K

2294 Hill Rd

Sister Bay, WI

10866 Birchwood Dr - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI

$695K

10866 Birchwood Dr

10226 Woodcrest Rd - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI

$875K

10226 Woodcrest Rd

More listings

More from Sister Bay

More active listings from across the Sister Bay market

10712 Timber Ridge Cr, Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$369K

10712 Timber Ridge Cr

Sister Bay, WI

2 bd2 ba1,216
10570 BAY RIDGE Place, Sister Bay, WI
Condo

$369K

10570 BAY RIDGE Place

Sister Bay, WI

2 bd2 ba1,100
2294 Hill Rd, Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$541K

2294 Hill Rd

Sister Bay, WI

3 bd2 ba2,000
10866 Birchwood Dr, Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$695K

10866 Birchwood Dr

Sister Bay, WI

2 bd2 ba1,852
10226 Woodcrest Rd, Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$875K

10226 Woodcrest Rd

Sister Bay, WI

3 bd3 ba3,236
10226 WOODCREST Road, Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$875K

10226 WOODCREST Road

Sister Bay, WI

3 bd3 ba3,236
10685 Commodore Cir, Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$1.3M

10685 Commodore Cir

Sister Bay, WI

4 bd5 ba3,420
2680 German Rd, Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$1.5M

2680 German Rd

Sister Bay, WI

4 bd3 ba3,000
Browse

Homes for Sale in Sister Bay

Every active listing in Sister Bay, browsable page by page.

Hill Rd lot: 3A - Land for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Land

$250K

Hill Rd lot: 3A

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
Hill Rd lot: 3B - Land for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Land

$250K

Hill Rd lot: 3B

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
Hill Rd lot: 4B - Land for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Land

$250K

Hill Rd lot: 4B

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
Hill Rd lot: 4A - Land for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Land

$250K

Hill Rd lot: 4A

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
9498 Town Line Dr - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$795K

9498 Town Line Dr

Sister Bay, WI

3 bd2 ba1,360
10640 N HIGHLAND Road - Condo for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Condo

$400K

10640 N HIGHLAND Road

Sister Bay, WI

2 bd2 ba1,300
Settlement Ln - Land for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Land

$280K

Settlement Ln

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
Beach Rd - Land for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Land

$449K

Beach Rd

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
2457 Bay Shore Dr - Commercial for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Commercial

$1.3M

2457 Bay Shore Dr

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba3,201
10506 STATE HIGHWAY 57 - Condo for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Condo

$230K

10506 STATE HIGHWAY 57

Sister Bay, WI

2 bd2 ba910
10506 Hwy 57 - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$230K

10506 Hwy 57

Sister Bay, WI

2 bd2 ba910
11041 W LIBERTY PARK Circle - Land for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Land

$160K

11041 W LIBERTY PARK Circle

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
11033 W LIBERTY PARK Circle - Land for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Land

$190K

11033 W LIBERTY PARK Circle

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
11037 W LIBERTY PARK Circle - Land for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Land

$160K

11037 W LIBERTY PARK Circle

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
11027 W LIBERTY PARK Circle - Land for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Land

$700K

11027 W LIBERTY PARK Circle

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
11023 W LIBERTY PARK Circle - Land for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Land

$190K

11023 W LIBERTY PARK Circle

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
10650 MILL Lane - Land for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Land

$200K

10650 MILL Lane

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
10650 Mill Ln - Land for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Land

$175K

10650 Mill Ln

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
2639 Settlement Rd - Land for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Land

$840K

2639 Settlement Rd

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
2680 German Rd - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$1.5M

2680 German Rd

Sister Bay, WI

4 bd3 ba3,000
2294 Hill Rd - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$541K

2294 Hill Rd

Sister Bay, WI

3 bd2 ba2,000
West Lot County Rd ZZ - Land for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Land

$425K

West Lot County Rd ZZ

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
10177 Orchard Dr - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$1.0M

10177 Orchard Dr

Sister Bay, WI

2 bd4 ba2,986
10570 BAY RIDGE Place - Condo for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Condo

$369K

10570 BAY RIDGE Place

Sister Bay, WI

2 bd2 ba1,100
10697 Timber Ridge Cr - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$360K

10697 Timber Ridge Cr

Sister Bay, WI

2 bd1 ba900
10649 N Bay Shore Dr - Commercial for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Commercial

$1.2M

10649 N Bay Shore Dr

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba676
2477 Bay Shore Dr - Commercial for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Commercial

$450K

2477 Bay Shore Dr

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba1,470
10701 Timber Ridge Cr - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$340K

10701 Timber Ridge Cr

Sister Bay, WI

2 bd1 ba900
2363 Mill Rd - Commercial for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Commercial

$525K

2363 Mill Rd

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba1,380
10712 Timber Ridge Cr - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$369K

10712 Timber Ridge Cr

Sister Bay, WI

2 bd2 ba1,216
10844 N Spring Rd - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$546K

10844 N Spring Rd

Sister Bay, WI

3 bd2 ba1,196
10844 N SPRING Road - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$546K

10844 N SPRING Road

Sister Bay, WI

3 bd2 ba1,061
10685 Commodore Cir - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$1.3M

10685 Commodore Cir

Sister Bay, WI

4 bd5 ba3,420
10893 N Bay Shore Dr - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$5.0M

10893 N Bay Shore Dr

Sister Bay, WI

3 bd4 ba2,500
10471 Country Ln - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$1.5M

10471 Country Ln

Sister Bay, WI

1 bd1 ba610
9996 Woodcrest Rd - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$975K

9996 Woodcrest Rd

Sister Bay, WI

3 bd2 ba1,626
10579 COUNTRY WALK Lane - Commercial for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Commercial

$199K

10579 COUNTRY WALK Lane

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
10471 COUNTRY Lane - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$1.5M

10471 COUNTRY Lane

Sister Bay, WI

1 bd1 ba610
10783A County Rd ZZ - Commercial for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Commercial

$199K

10783A County Rd ZZ

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
10783A County Rd ZZ - Land for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Land

$199K

10783A County Rd ZZ

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
10579 Country Walk Ln - Commercial for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Commercial

$199K

10579 Country Walk Ln

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba1,040
10471 Country Ln - Commercial for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Commercial

$1.5M

10471 Country Ln

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba1,347
Hillcrest Rd - Land for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Land

$299K

Hillcrest Rd

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
10226 Woodcrest Rd - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$875K

10226 Woodcrest Rd

Sister Bay, WI

3 bd3 ba3,236
10226 WOODCREST Road - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$875K

10226 WOODCREST Road

Sister Bay, WI

3 bd3 ba3,236
Beach Rd - Land for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Land

$479K

Beach Rd

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
HWY 57 - Land for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Land

$240K

HWY 57

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
Hwy 57 - Land for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Land

$240K

Hwy 57

Sister Bay, WI

0 bd0 ba0
1863 Hill Rd - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$999K

1863 Hill Rd

Sister Bay, WI

2 bd3 ba1,802
1980 SCANDIA Road - Single Family for sale in Sister Bay, WI
Single Family

$575K

1980 SCANDIA Road

Sister Bay, WI

3 bd1 ba1,179

Showing 1–50 of 80 · Page 1 of 2

Beyond the listings

Continue exploring Sister Bay

Turn the listings into a short list with a clearer read on the Sister Bay market, its neighborhoods, and the home features that matter to you.

Refine Sister Bay searchAll Wisconsin homes
Local market guide

Sister Bay Housing Market

Browse 80 active listings in Sister Bay, Wisconsin. The average list price for this active inventory is $640,992. Compare the price and property details reported in each listing.

Average list price $640,992 · Range $48,000–$4,950,000 · 80 active listings

Buyer questions

Frequently Asked Questions

How many active listings are available in Sister Bay, Wisconsin?

The current inventory contains 80 active listings in Sister Bay, WI.

What is the average list price in Sister Bay, Wisconsin?

The average list price among current active listings in Sister Bay, WI is $640,992. Current list prices range from $48,000 to $4,950,000.

What is the average days on market for active listings in Sister Bay?

Current active listings in Sister Bay, WI report an average of 137 days on market.

What is the average list price per square foot in Sister Bay?

The average list price per square foot among current active listings in Sister Bay, WI is $648.

Shape your search

Browse Sister Bay by home feature

Homes with Solar FeaturesHomes with EV ChargersHomes with PoolsWaterfront HomesHomes with ViewsHomes with Recorded Price ReductionsListings Added to PropertySimple in the Past 7 DaysHomes Built Since 2024

Nationwide collections

Explore by listing details

Waterfront ListingsListings Marked WaterfrontListings in Mountain StatesSix-State CollectionMulti-Family & Commercial ListingsListings by Property TypeListings with 3+ BedroomsThree or More BedroomsListings Priced at $1.5M+Listings by Asking PriceListings Built Since 2015Listings by Year Built

Ready to make the list yours?

Use the full search to set your price, beds, property type, and must-have features for Sister Bay.

Search Sister Bay homes