Curious about this home?

Ask anything — no agents, no pressure

Try asking

About This Home

This 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom single family at 233 Madison Street in Sag Harbor, NY is listed for $3,995,000 ($1,665 per sqft). Built in 1840, the home offers 2,400 sqft of living space on a 0.21 acres lot.

Agent Description

Enjoy the Hamptons moments from the fabulous Village of Sag Harbor in this newly listed historic home, now available for sale! Built in the 1840s and completely renovated, this charming home blends old-world charm with modern details. This home is truly one of the jewels of Sag Harbor Village; don't let the exterior fool you, as the house is expansive and generous in size and great for entertaining.

Ready to accommodate with 4 bedrooms and 3 baths and original wide plank flooring throughout the open floor plan. Plus, gorgeous stone flooring in the fully equipped Chef's kitchen. Double-height ceilings fill the great room and dining room with beaming natural light.

Also on the main level is office space that can be used as a 4th bedroom as it features 2 closets, a sitting room, and a family room. All bedrooms are situated on their own private level, and the bright ensuite primary encompasses the entire upper level for the utmost privacy.

The exterior is simply fabulous, with lovely professionally landscaped grounds with Hydrangea flanking both sides of the pool area and fencing on 4 sides for privacy. The inground heated pool with a stone patio, chaise lounge chairs, and umbrellas make this a perfect spot to relax after a day on the beach.

Grill and prepare fabulous dinners for your guests while they dip in the pool. All this is just minutes from the Historic Whaling Village of Sag Harbor with its many restaurants, theatres, and shops. Make sure to stroll down to Long Wharf to watch the Yachts and have homemade ice cream.

Key Features

  • Built in 1840
  • 0.21 acre lot
  • Fireplace

Property Details

3 full
1840

Amenities

FireplaceHardwoodBasement

Monthly Cost Estimate

$21,366/mo

20% down · 6.5% · 30 years

Principal$2,889
Interest$17,312
Insurance$1,165

Estimates only. Actual payments may vary.

Location

233 Madison Street

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Property Details

Flooring

Hardwood

Parking

Garage

Heating

Fireplace(s)Forced Air

Cooling

Central Air

Appliances

DishwasherMicrowaveRefrigeratorWasher

Questions & Answers

This 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom single family at 233 Madison Street is listed at $3,995,000 ($1,665/sqft). The estimated monthly payment is $17,312 based on 20% down at 6.5% interest.

Key features include: Built in 1840, 0.21 acre lot, Fireplace.

This property is listed by Susan M. Lahrman and can be reached at 6315375454 or SLahrman@Saunders.com.

Similar Homes in Sag Harbor

View all
SL

Susan M. Lahrman

Agent at Saunders & Associates

(631) 537-5454

Listed by Saunders & Associates · View on Broker Site

MLS# 11586730· Source: listhub· Updated 192 days ago

Copyright © 2026 My State MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

233 Madison Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Open this listing in: