New York

Homes for Sale in Middle Island — Page 2

57 listings

Avg $512,124

110 days avg

Search All 57 Homes

Explore

Market Overview

Middle Island Real Estate at a Glance

Current market statistics for Middle Island, NY

Active Listings

$512K

Avg Price

$350

Price/Sqft

110

Avg Days

Price Range

From

$170,000

$1,235,000

Property Types

Condo

Single Family

Other

Page 2

Homes for Sale in Middle Island

Every active listing in Middle Island, browsable page by page.

Commercial

$599K

217 Middle Country Road

Middle Island, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Condo

$250K

280 Artist Lake Drive

Middle Island, NY

1 bd1 ba836

Land

$235K

Daniel Lane

Middle Island, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Land

$170K

VL Daniel Lane

Middle Island, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Land

$300K

Middle Country Road

Middle Island, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Showing 51–55 of 57 · Page 2 of 2

Beyond the listings

Continue exploring Middle Island

Turn the listings into a short list with a clearer read on the Middle Island market, its neighborhoods, and the home features that matter to you.

Refine Middle Island search All New York homes

Shape your search

Browse Middle Island by home feature

Homes with Solar Features Homes with EV Chargers Homes with Pools Waterfront Homes Homes with Views Homes with Recorded Price Reductions Listings Added to PropertySimple in the Past 7 Days Homes Built Since 2024

Nationwide collections

Explore by listing details

Waterfront ListingsListings Marked Waterfront Listings in Mountain StatesSix-State Collection Multi-Family & Commercial ListingsListings by Property Type Listings with 3+ BedroomsThree or More Bedrooms Listings Priced at $1.5M+Listings by Asking Price Listings Built Since 2015Listings by Year Built

Ready to make the list yours?

Use the full search to set your price, beds, property type, and must-have features for Middle Island.

Search Middle Island homes