Homes for Sale in Middle Island
“59 active listings in Middle Island, New York · Average list price $532,105”
Middle Island Real Estate at a Glance
Current market statistics for Middle Island, NY
59
Active Listings
$532K
Avg Price
$354
Price/Sqft
111
Avg Days
Price Range
From
$170,000
To
$1,235,000
Property Types
Nearby Cities
Explore homes for sale in cities near Middle Island, New York
Homes to Explore
Active listings from the middle island collection
More from Middle Island
More active listings from across the Middle Island market
$269K
244 Lake Pointe Circle
Middle Island, NY
$350K
196 Fairview Circle
Middle Island, NY
$490K
5 Robert Lane
Middle Island, NY
$490K
5 Robert Lane
Middle Island, NY
$575K
33 Perri Circle
Middle Island, NY
$519K
1 Jennifer Lane
Middle Island, NY
$850K
1 Lake Drive
Middle Island, NY
$620K
24 Half Mile Road
Middle Island, NY
Homes for Sale in Middle Island
Every active listing in Middle Island, browsable page by page.
$749K
66 Kate Circle
Middle Island, NY
$420K
194 Haddon Hollow Court
Middle Island, NY
$688K
29 Madison Circle
Middle Island, NY
$688K
29 Madison Circle
Middle Island, NY
$195K
62 Baily Court
Middle Island, NY
$620K
24 Half Mile Road
Middle Island, NY
$325K
173 Fairview Circle
Middle Island, NY
$325K
173 Fairview Circle
Middle Island, NY
$575K
33 Perri Circle
Middle Island, NY
$325K
80 Fairview Circle
Middle Island, NY
$725K
5 Heather Court
Middle Island, NY
$219K
63 Bailey Court
Middle Island, NY
$545K
63 Madison Circle
Middle Island, NY
$509K
14 Sophia Drive
Middle Island, NY
$274K
94 Gauguin Court
Middle Island, NY
$675K
3 Putter Lane
Middle Island, NY
$620K
56 E Bartlett Road
Middle Island, NY
$675K
3 Putter Lane
Middle Island, NY
$420K
65 Eric Drive
Middle Island, NY
$350K
196 Fairview Circle
Middle Island, NY
$519K
1 Jennifer Lane
Middle Island, NY
$519K
1 Jennifer Lane
Middle Island, NY
$500K
8 Lavern Drive
Middle Island, NY
$400K
764 Birchwood Park Drive
Middle Island, NY
$500K
33 Pine Cone Street
Middle Island, NY
$500K
33 Pine Cone Street
Middle Island, NY
$535K
41 Madison Circle
Middle Island, NY
$500K
840 Birchwood Park Drive
Middle Island, NY
$500K
840 Birchwood Park Drive
Middle Island, NY
$460K
717 Spring Lake Drive
Middle Island, NY
$270K
194 Artist Lake Drive
Middle Island, NY
$370K
69 Fairview Circle
Middle Island, NY
$959K
7 Sander Court
Middle Island, NY
$489K
24 Oakcrest Avenue
Middle Island, NY
$355K
282 Fairview Circle
Middle Island, NY
$575K
5 Charley Lane
Middle Island, NY
$490K
10 Casey Lane
Middle Island, NY
$1.2M
42 E Bartlett Road
Middle Island, NY
$269K
244 Lake Pointe Circle
Middle Island, NY
$636K
8 Jennifer Lane
Middle Island, NY
$374K
137 Fieldstone Court
Middle Island, NY
$490K
5 Robert Lane
Middle Island, NY
$490K
5 Robert Lane
Middle Island, NY
$1.2M
VL Coram Swezeytown Road
Middle Island, NY
$870K
3 Sander Court
Middle Island, NY
$179K
28 Bailey Court
Middle Island, NY
$850K
1 Lake Drive
Middle Island, NY
$599K
217 Middle Country Road
Middle Island, NY
$250K
280 Artist Lake Drive
Middle Island, NY
$235K
Daniel Lane
Middle Island, NY
Showing 1–50 of 59 · Page 1 of 2
Continue exploring Middle Island
Turn the listings into a short list with a clearer read on the Middle Island market, its neighborhoods, and the home features that matter to you.
Middle Island Housing Market
Browse 59 active listings in Middle Island, New York. The average list price for this active inventory is $532,105. Compare the price and property details reported in each listing.
Average list price $532,105 · Range $170,000–$1,235,000 · 59 active listings
Frequently Asked Questions
How many active listings are available in Middle Island, New York?
What is the average list price in Middle Island, New York?
What is the average days on market for active listings in Middle Island?
What is the average list price per square foot in Middle Island?
Shape your search
Browse Middle Island by home feature
Nationwide collections
Explore by listing details
Ready to make the list yours?
Use the full search to set your price, beds, property type, and must-have features for Middle Island.