Homes for Sale in Middletown
“Discover your next home in Middletown”
Middletown Real Estate at a Glance
Current market statistics for Middletown, NY
97
Active Listings
$544K
Avg Price
$425K
Median Price
1,834
Avg Sqft
110
Avg Days
Price Range
From
$39,000
To
$2,575,000
Editor's Picks
Our curated selection of the finest middletown homes
More Middletown Homes
More standout listings from across the Middletown market
$799K
225 Van Duzer Road
Middletown, NY
$470K
“3 Bedroom 3 Bath Condo in Maple Fields Middletown NY 1723 Sq Ft Built 2017”
22 Atwood Drive
Middletown, NY
$400K
“3 Bedroom 2 Bath Split Level Single Family Home on Cul-de-Sac in Middletown, NY”
12 Todd Drive
Middletown, NY
$155K
“1 Bedroom 1 Bath Single Family Home Built 1903 on 0.07 Acre Lot in Middletown NY”
45 Knapp Avenue
Middletown, NY
$844K
238 S Centerville Road
Middletown, NY
$500K
6 Kennedy Terrace
Middletown, NY
$393K
“1890 Built 3 Bedroom Single Family Home on Corner Lot Middletown NY”
1 Chestnut Street
Middletown, NY
$300K
2 S Aspen Road
Middletown, NY
Homes for Sale in Middletown
Every active listing in Middletown, browsable page by page.
$175K
385 Midland Lake Road
Middletown, NY
$629K
744 Mt Hope Road
Middletown, NY
$395K
24 Mountain Avenue
Middletown, NY
$499K
12 Walnut Lane
Middletown, NY
$260K
29 Parsons Lane
Middletown, NY
$500K
678 Prosperous Valley Road
Middletown, NY
$550K
181 Stony Ford Road
Middletown, NY
$300K
196 Cottage Street
Middletown, NY
$185K
326 Concord Lane
Middletown, NY
$360K
101 N Beacon Street
Middletown, NY
$399K
4 Lorelei Drive
Middletown, NY
$400K
70 Peach Place
Middletown, NY
$750K
512 County Route 49
Middletown, NY
$550K
1 Hulse Street
Middletown, NY
$485K
1 High Ridge Lane
Middletown, NY
$215K
429 Van Burenville Road
Middletown, NY
$500K
6 Kennedy Terrace
Middletown, NY
$450K
37 Monhagen Avenue
Middletown, NY
$279K
19 Hulse Avenue
Middletown, NY
$289K
4 Hulse Street
Middletown, NY
$398K
33 Walker Street
Middletown, NY
$399K
19 Putters Way
Middletown, NY
$225K
45 John Street
Middletown, NY
$165K
226 Concord Lane
Middletown, NY
$585K
2078 Route 6
Middletown, NY
$400K
21 Evan Court
Middletown, NY
$520K
29 Avoncroft Lane
Middletown, NY
$393K
“1890 Built 3 Bedroom Single Family Home on Corner Lot Middletown NY”
1 Chestnut Street
Middletown, NY
$499K
37 California Drive
Middletown, NY
$70K
301 3rd Avenue
Middletown, NY
$299K
21 Dolson Avenue
Middletown, NY
$340K
5 Kendal Lane
Middletown, NY
$300K
2 S Aspen Road
Middletown, NY
$435K
60 Peach Place
Middletown, NY
$575K
20 John Street
Middletown, NY
$575K
180 Mt Orange Road
Middletown, NY
$525K
225 Upper Road
Middletown, NY
$400K
568 County Route 49
Middletown, NY
$625K
45 Randall Heights
Middletown, NY
$1.6M
430 Kirbytown Road
Middletown, NY
$600K
215 Linden Avenue
Middletown, NY
$400K
25 Mill Street
Middletown, NY
$399K
4 Saint Eve Court
Middletown, NY
$400K
341 Highland Ave Extension
Middletown, NY
$150K
32 Hidden Valley Drive
Middletown, NY
$599K
317 E Main Street
Middletown, NY
$400K
“3 Bedroom 2 Bath Split Level Single Family Home on Cul-de-Sac in Middletown, NY”
12 Todd Drive
Middletown, NY
$1.2M
2 White Horse Road
Middletown, NY
$555K
29 Murray Road
Middletown, NY
$425K
83 Deer Ct Drive
Middletown, NY
Showing 1–50 of 97 · Page 1 of 2
Continue exploring Middletown
Turn the listings into a short list with a clearer read on the Middletown market, its neighborhoods, and the home features that matter to you.
Middletown Housing Market
Middletown, New York has 97 homes for sale, with a median list price of $425,000. Browse active listings, filter by price, beds, and property type, and compare homes across the Middletown market.
Median list price $425,000 · Range $39,000–$2,575,000 · 97 active listings
Frequently Asked Questions
How many homes are for sale in Middletown, New York?
What is the average home price in Middletown, New York?
What is the median home price in Middletown?
How long do homes stay on the market in Middletown?
Shape your search
Browse Middletown by home feature
Ready to make the list yours?
Use the full search to set your price, beds, property type, and must-have features for Middletown.