Homes for Sale in Monticello
“Discover your next home in Monticello”
Monticello Real Estate at a Glance
Current market statistics for Monticello, NY
51
Active Listings
$820K
Avg Price
$489K
Median Price
1,856
Avg Sqft
163
Avg Days
Price Range
From
$45,000
To
$6,999,900
Editor's Picks
Our curated selection of the finest monticello homes
More Monticello Homes
More standout listings from across the Monticello market
$1.6M
657 Sackett Lake Road
Monticello, NY
$499K
“Renovated 4-Unit Office Single Family Home at 80 Jefferson Street, Monticello, NY on 0.43 Acres”
80 Jefferson Street
Monticello, NY
$430K
39 Dingle Daisy Road
Monticello, NY
$160K
18 forsythia Drive
Monticello, NY
$1.9M
35 Serenity Lane
Monticello, NY
$650K
209 Gregory Road
Monticello, NY
$375K
9 Smith Street
Monticello, NY
$299K
253 Harris Bushville Road
Monticello, NY
Homes for Sale in Monticello
Every active listing in Monticello, browsable page by page.
$165K
64 Moon Manor Road
Monticello, NY
$145K
73 Harmony Lane
Monticello, NY
$375K
9 Smith Street
Monticello, NY
$750K
16 Gregory Road
Monticello, NY
$160K
18 forsythia Drive
Monticello, NY
$749K
107 Jefferson Street
Monticello, NY
$349K
“6 Bedroom 2 Bathroom Two-Family Home Built 1951 in Monticello NY”
14 Smith Street
Monticello, NY
$3.2M
457 Broadway
Monticello, NY
$299K
286 Dingle Daisy Road
Monticello, NY
$299K
253 Harris Bushville Road
Monticello, NY
$650K
224 Lake Shore Drive
Monticello, NY
$800K
832 State Route 17B
Monticello, NY
$800K
852 State Route 17B
Monticello, NY
$430K
39 Dingle Daisy Road
Monticello, NY
$425K
370 Starlight Road
Monticello, NY
$489K
140 Starlight Dr
Monticello, NY
$460K
230 Old Route 17
Monticello, NY
$352K
10 Hanover Drive
Monticello, NY
$1.6M
657 Sackett Lake Road
Monticello, NY
$2.5M
235 Cantrell Road
Monticello, NY
$1.2M
47 Cooper Road
Monticello, NY
$395K
7 Jenn Lane
Monticello, NY
$275K
23 Spring Street
Monticello, NY
$275K
165 Park Avenue
Monticello, NY
$650K
209 Gregory Road
Monticello, NY
$1.9M
35 Serenity Lane
Monticello, NY
$275K
553 Cold Spring
Monticello, NY
$600K
97 Liberty Street
Monticello, NY
$369K
365 E Broadway
Monticello, NY
$499K
“Renovated 4-Unit Office Single Family Home at 80 Jefferson Street, Monticello, NY on 0.43 Acres”
80 Jefferson Street
Monticello, NY
$775K
740 Southwoods Drive
Monticello, NY
$45K
8 Starlight Drive
Monticello, NY
$800K
3520 State Route 42
Monticello, NY
$365K
105 Wood Avenue
Monticello, NY
$150K
458 Broadway
Monticello, NY
$600K
“0.23 Acre Land Zoned Commercial and Residential at 1 Bennet Street Monticello NY”
1 Bennet Street
Monticello, NY
$250K
751 Sackett Lake Road
Monticello, NY
$65K
25 Pansy Lane
Monticello, NY
$649K
14 Lena Road
Monticello, NY
$298K
279 Cold Spring Road
Monticello, NY
$800K
45 Coopers Corner Road
Monticello, NY
$975K
36 Cold Spring Road
Monticello, NY
$1.2M
3 old congress lane
Monticello, NY
$105K
“2021 2-Bedroom 2-Bath Mobile Home on State Route 17B in Monticello, NY”
394 State Route 17B Lot#19
Monticello, NY
$749K
28 Raceway Road
Monticello, NY
$1.8M
28 Raceway Road
Monticello, NY
$335K
31 Forestburgh Road
Monticello, NY
$650K
269 State Route 17b
Monticello, NY
$449K
485 Broadway
Monticello, NY
$7.0M
530 W Broadway
Monticello, NY
Showing 1–50 of 51 · Page 1 of 2
Continue exploring Monticello
Turn the listings into a short list with a clearer read on the Monticello market, its neighborhoods, and the home features that matter to you.
Monticello Housing Market
Monticello, New York has 51 homes for sale, with a median list price of $489,000. Browse active listings, filter by price, beds, and property type, and compare homes across the Monticello market.
Median list price $489,000 · Range $45,000–$6,999,900 · 51 active listings
Frequently Asked Questions
How many homes are for sale in Monticello, New York?
What is the average home price in Monticello, New York?
What is the median home price in Monticello?
How long do homes stay on the market in Monticello?
Shape your search
Browse Monticello by home feature
Ready to make the list yours?
Use the full search to set your price, beds, property type, and must-have features for Monticello.