New York

Homes for Sale in Monticello

“78 active listings in Monticello, New York · Average list price $991,861”

78 listings

Avg $991,861

172 days avg

Search All 78 Homes

Explore

Market Overview

Monticello Real Estate at a Glance

Current market statistics for Monticello, NY

Active Listings

$992K

Avg Price

$326

Price/Sqft

172

Avg Days

Price Range

From

$60,000

$8,500,000

Property Types

Nearby Cities

Explore homes for sale in cities near Monticello, New York

Listing selection

Homes to Explore

Active listings from the monticello collection

$135K

18 forsythia Drive

Monticello, NY

$289K

62 Clinton Avenue

Monticello, NY

$389K

219 Rose Valley Road

Monticello, NY

$375K

39 Dingle Daisy Road

$549K

97 Liberty Street

More listings

Homes for Sale in Monticello

Every active listing in Monticello, browsable page by page.

Single Family

$389K

219 Rose Valley Road

Monticello, NY

3 bd6 ba4,158

Single Family

$329K

115 Park Avenue

Monticello, NY

3 bd2 ba1,592

Single Family

$549K

97 Liberty Street

Monticello, NY

4 bd4 ba3,764

Single Family

$85K

8 Gloucester Court

Monticello, NY

3 bd2 ba1,080

Single Family

$299K

3 Edinburgh Lane

Monticello, NY

2 bd2 ba1,400

Single Family

$349K

105 Wood Avenue

Monticello, NY

4 bd2 ba1,768

Commercial

$950K

36 Cold Spring Road

Monticello, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Single Family

$2.5M

657 Sackett Lake Road

Monticello, NY

4 bd4 ba3,520

Condo

$219K

29 Harmony Lane

Monticello, NY

3 bd2 ba1,300

Single Family

$650K

209 Gregory Road

Monticello, NY

3 bd2 ba2,800

Single Family

$300K

43 Melody Lake Drive

Monticello, NY

4 bd2 ba1,796

Single Family

$824K

162 Lakeshore Drive

Monticello, NY

4 bd3 ba2,184

Single Family

$310K

93 Starlight Drive

Monticello, NY

2 bd1 ba828

Single Family

$279K

6 Bristol Lane

Monticello, NY

2 bd2 ba1,350

Single Family

$524K

140 Starlight Drive

Monticello, NY

4 bd3 ba2,496

Single Family

$215K

432 Southwoods Drive

Monticello, NY

2 bd1 ba1,026

Land

$950K

59 Lanahan Road

Monticello, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Single Family

$460K

6 Water Lilly Lane

Monticello, NY

3 bd3 ba1,112

Land

$449K

Town Park Rd

Monticello, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Single Family

$400K

370 Starlight Road

Monticello, NY

2 bd2 ba1,080

Single Family

$435K

3 Water Lilly Lane

Monticello, NY

3 bd3 ba1,112

Commercial

$700K

30 Woodcliff Avenue

Monticello, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Single Family

$420K

8 Willow Lane

Monticello, NY

3 bd2 ba1,200

Single Family

$425K

14 Willow Lane

Monticello, NY

3 bd3 ba1,471

Land

$60K

80 High Street

Monticello, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Townhouse

$240K

21 Harmony Mill Lane

Monticello, NY

3 bd2 ba1,200

Commercial

$8.5M

456 Broadway

Monticello, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Commercial

$799K

458 Broadway

Monticello, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Commercial

$899K

500 Broadway

Monticello, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Commercial

$1.7M

456 Broadway

Monticello, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Commercial

$1.1M

493 Broadway

Monticello, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Commercial

$1.3M

497 Broadway

Monticello, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Land

$399K

628 Sackett Lake Road

Monticello, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Single Family

$500K

463 Rose Valley Road

Monticello, NY

5 bd2 ba2,122

Commercial

$1.7M

452 Broadway

Monticello, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Land

$4.0M

Hilltop Road

Monticello, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Single Family

$4.0M

118 Hilltop Road

Monticello, NY

4 bd4 ba3,172

Single Family

$1.1M

35 Kroeger Road

Monticello, NY

3 bd4 ba1,484

Single Family

$289K

62 Clinton Avenue

Monticello, NY

4 bd2 ba1,568

Single Family

$1.4M

143 S Maplewood Road

Monticello, NY

7 bd5 ba1,920

Single Family

$165K

64 Moon Manor Road

Monticello, NY

3 bd2 ba1,464

Single Family

$145K

73 Harmony Lane

Monticello, NY

3 bd2 ba1,200

Single Family

$135K

18 forsythia Drive

Monticello, NY

3 bd3 ba1,680

Commercial

$749K

107 Jefferson Street

Monticello, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Commercial

$3.0M

457 Broadway

Monticello, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Single Family

$299K

286 Dingle Daisy Road

Monticello, NY

2 bd1 ba1,190

Commercial

$800K

852 State Route 17B

Monticello, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Single Family

$800K

832 State Route 17B

Monticello, NY

3 bd2 ba1,196

Single Family

$375K

39 Dingle Daisy Road

Monticello, NY

5 bd2 ba2,062

Single Family

$460K

230 Old Route 17

Monticello, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Showing 1–50 of 78 · Page 1 of 2

Beyond the listings

Continue exploring Monticello

Turn the listings into a short list with a clearer read on the Monticello market, its neighborhoods, and the home features that matter to you.

Refine Monticello search All New York homes

Local market guide

Monticello Housing Market

Browse 78 active listings in Monticello, New York. The average list price for this active inventory is $991,861. Compare the price and property details reported in each listing.

Average list price $991,861 · Range $60,000–$8,500,000 · 78 active listings

Buyer questions

Frequently Asked Questions

How many active listings are available in Monticello, New York?

The current inventory contains 78 active listings in Monticello, NY.

What is the average list price in Monticello, New York?

The average list price among current active listings in Monticello, NY is $991,861. Current list prices range from $60,000 to $8,500,000.

What is the average days on market for active listings in Monticello?

Current active listings in Monticello, NY report an average of 172 days on market.

What is the average list price per square foot in Monticello?

The average list price per square foot among current active listings in Monticello, NY is $326.

Shape your search

Browse Monticello by home feature

Homes with Solar Features Homes with EV Chargers Homes with Pools Waterfront Homes Homes with Views Homes with Recorded Price Reductions Listings Added to PropertySimple in the Past 7 Days Homes Built Since 2024

Nationwide collections

Explore by listing details

Waterfront ListingsListings Marked Waterfront Listings in Mountain StatesSix-State Collection Multi-Family & Commercial ListingsListings by Property Type Listings with 3+ BedroomsThree or More Bedrooms Listings Priced at $1.5M+Listings by Asking Price Listings Built Since 2015Listings by Year Built

Ready to make the list yours?

Use the full search to set your price, beds, property type, and must-have features for Monticello.

Search Monticello homes

Homes for Sale in Monticello

Monticello Real Estate at a Glance

Price Range

Property Types

Nearby Cities

Homes to Explore

More from Monticello

18 forsythia Drive

62 Clinton Avenue

219 Rose Valley Road

39 Dingle Daisy Road

97 Liberty Street

140 Starlight Drive

114 Levine Road

235 Cantrell Road

Homes for Sale in Monticello

219 Rose Valley Road

115 Park Avenue

97 Liberty Street

8 Gloucester Court

3 Edinburgh Lane

105 Wood Avenue

36 Cold Spring Road

657 Sackett Lake Road

29 Harmony Lane

209 Gregory Road

43 Melody Lake Drive

162 Lakeshore Drive

93 Starlight Drive

6 Bristol Lane

140 Starlight Drive

432 Southwoods Drive

59 Lanahan Road

6 Water Lilly Lane

Town Park Rd

370 Starlight Road

3 Water Lilly Lane

30 Woodcliff Avenue

8 Willow Lane

14 Willow Lane

80 High Street

21 Harmony Mill Lane

456 Broadway

458 Broadway

500 Broadway

456 Broadway

493 Broadway

497 Broadway

628 Sackett Lake Road

463 Rose Valley Road

452 Broadway

Hilltop Road

118 Hilltop Road

35 Kroeger Road

62 Clinton Avenue

143 S Maplewood Road

64 Moon Manor Road

73 Harmony Lane

18 forsythia Drive

107 Jefferson Street

457 Broadway

286 Dingle Daisy Road

852 State Route 17B

832 State Route 17B

39 Dingle Daisy Road

230 Old Route 17

Monticello Housing Market

Frequently Asked Questions

How many active listings are available in Monticello, New York?

What is the average list price in Monticello, New York?

What is the average days on market for active listings in Monticello?

What is the average list price per square foot in Monticello?

Browse Monticello by home feature

Explore by listing details

Ready to make the list yours?