Homes for Sale in Shirley
“Discover your next home in Shirley”
Shirley Real Estate at a Glance
Current market statistics for Shirley, NY
51
Active Listings
$560K
Avg Price
$550K
Median Price
1,570
Avg Sqft
89
Avg Days
Price Range
From
$89,999
To
$1,429,900
Editor's Picks
Our curated selection of the finest shirley homes
More Shirley Homes
More standout listings from across the Shirley market
$759K
52 Victory Avenue
Shirley, NY
$570K
“Shirley NY 6 Bedroom 3 Bath Single Family Home Built 1989 on 0.23 Acre Lot”
12 Heston Road
Shirley, NY
$499K
71 Pinewood Drive
Shirley, NY
$389K
“3 Bedroom Single Family Home Built in 1951 in Shirley, NY”
89 Argyle Drive
Shirley, NY
$725K
432 Puritan Drive
Shirley, NY
$550K
69 Appel Drive E
Shirley, NY
$515K
41 Greentree Court
Shirley, NY
$400K
“3 Bedroom Single Family Home in Shirley NY 1125 Sq Ft Built 1974”
123 St George Drive E
Shirley, NY
Homes for Sale in Shirley
Every active listing in Shirley, browsable page by page.
$389K
“3 Bedroom Single Family Home Built in 1951 in Shirley, NY”
89 Argyle Drive
Shirley, NY
$495K
438 Auborn Avenue
Shirley, NY
$425K
22 Cricket Court
Shirley, NY
$470K
6 Malba Drive
Shirley, NY
$600K
19 Golden Gate Drive
Shirley, NY
$610K
90 Grandview Drive
Shirley, NY
$600K
19 Golden Gate Drive
Shirley, NY
$499K
71 Pinewood Drive
Shirley, NY
$759K
52 Victory Avenue
Shirley, NY
$550K
65 Winston Drive
Shirley, NY
$475K
50 Beatrice Drive
Shirley, NY
$600K
152 Grand Avenue
Shirley, NY
$499K
34 Windus Drive
Shirley, NY
$570K
“Shirley NY 6 Bedroom 3 Bath Single Family Home Built 1989 on 0.23 Acre Lot”
12 Heston Road
Shirley, NY
$550K
69 Appel Drive E
Shirley, NY
$485K
21 Probst Drive
Shirley, NY
$480K
19 Cypress Lane
Shirley, NY
$570K
18 Merrick Road
Shirley, NY
$575K
147 Baybright Drive E
Shirley, NY
$660K
72 Concord Road
Shirley, NY
$495K
1 Heston Road
Shirley, NY
$540K
40 Greentree Court
Shirley, NY
$800K
508 Starlight Drive
Shirley, NY
$680K
30 Park Avenue
Shirley, NY
$540K
55 William Floyd Parkway
Shirley, NY
$560K
46 Rockledge Drive
Shirley, NY
$550K
158 William Floyd Parkway
Shirley, NY
$780K
48 Westwood Drive
Shirley, NY
$559K
17 Greentree Court
Shirley, NY
$725K
432 Puritan Drive
Shirley, NY
$600K
198 Concord Road
Shirley, NY
$600K
198 Concord Road
Shirley, NY
$669K
39 Pinetop Drive
Shirley, NY
$450K
7 Hollywood Drive
Shirley, NY
$469K
43 Grand Avenue
Shirley, NY
$469K
41 Grand Avenue
Shirley, NY
$524K
159 Parkwood Drive
Shirley, NY
$750K
528 Lockwood Drive
Shirley, NY
$1.4M
72 Grandview Drive
Shirley, NY
$485K
127 Johns Neck Road
Shirley, NY
$400K
“3 Bedroom Single Family Home in Shirley NY 1125 Sq Ft Built 1974”
123 St George Drive E
Shirley, NY
$515K
41 Greentree Court
Shirley, NY
$500K
21 Greentree Court
Shirley, NY
$499K
6 Rugby Drive
Shirley, NY
$499K
15 Beatrice Drive
Shirley, NY
$499K
15 Beatrice Drive
Shirley, NY
$645K
7 Fairlawn Court
Shirley, NY
$560K
487 NEIGHBORHOOD ROAD
Shirley, NY
$580K
305 COMMACK Road
Shirley, NY
$239K
181 William Floyd Parkway
Shirley, NY
Showing 1–50 of 51 · Page 1 of 2
Continue exploring Shirley
Turn the listings into a short list with a clearer read on the Shirley market, its neighborhoods, and the home features that matter to you.
Shirley Housing Market
Shirley, New York has 51 homes for sale, with a median list price of $549,999. Browse active listings, filter by price, beds, and property type, and compare homes across the Shirley market.
Median list price $549,999 · Range $89,999–$1,429,900 · 51 active listings
Frequently Asked Questions
How many homes are for sale in Shirley, New York?
What is the average home price in Shirley, New York?
What is the median home price in Shirley?
How long do homes stay on the market in Shirley?
Shape your search
Browse Shirley by home feature
Ready to make the list yours?
Use the full search to set your price, beds, property type, and must-have features for Shirley.