New York
Waterfront Homes for Sale in Shirley
“Discover Waterfront Homes in Shirley, NY”
3 listings
Avg $853,300
Explore
Handpicked
Editor's Picks
Our curated selection of the finest waterfront homes homes
Featured
More Waterfront Homes
Discover more properties that match this lifestyle
About Waterfront Homes in Shirley
Shirley, NY currently features 3 waterfront properties on the market, with an average price of $853,300 and a range spanning from $485,000 to $1,429,900. These homes offer direct water access along the South Shore, making them ideal for buyers seeking coastal living in Suffolk County. The limited inventory highlights strong demand for waterfront living in this Long Island community.
Average listing price: $853,300 · 3 homes available
Frequently Asked Questions
Shirley offers a mix of single-family waterfront homes and cottages with direct bay access. With only 3 active listings, buyers have a rare opportunity to secure properties priced between $485,000 and $1,429,900.
At $853,300, Shirley’s average waterfront price is competitive for Long Island’s South Shore. This pricing reflects both the exclusivity of waterfront living and the limited supply of just 3 homes currently available.
Buyers should evaluate flood zones, dock permits, and seasonal water levels specific to Shirley’s shoreline. With inventory this low, acting quickly on listings between $485,000 and $1,429,900 is essential.