About This Home

This 6-bedroom, 4-bathroom single family at 75 S Penataquit Avenue in Bay Shore, NY is listed for $1,549,000 ($428 per sqft). Built in 1880, the home offers 3,617 sqft of living space on a 0.94 acres lot.

Key Features

  • Built in 1880
  • 0.94 acre lot
  • Private pool
  • Fireplace

Property Details

3 full, 1 half
2-car garage
1880

Amenities

PoolFireplaceHardwood
Listing Description

Lovingly restored and thoughtfully enhanced by its current owners, this remarkable 1880 residence reflects years of careful stewardship And substantial investment. Every update was made to elevate everyday living while honoring the home's character and architectural integrity.

Updates: 2021 : New Siding & Windows, New PVC & Aluminum Fencing. Leaf Filter on All Gutters 2021/2022 : Basement waterproofed ( Lifetime guarantee ) 2021/2022 : Pool heater & Filter 2022 : New Split Units 2023: Generator, 15 zone Sprinklers, Alarm system with 11 Cameras hooked up to Central Station, Doors 2024: New Kitchen & Appliances, Motorized

Shades in Living Room 2025: New driveway, New walkway and Stoops 2026: 2.5 New Bathrooms, with Soaker tub on 2nd floor and wonderful shower on third floor 2026: Newly sealed bricks around pool and back walkway.

Monthly Cost Estimate

$8,284/mo

20% down · 6.5% · 30 years

Principal$1,120
Interest$6,712
Insurance$452

Estimates only. Actual payments may vary.

Location

75 S Penataquit Avenue

Bay Shore, NY 11706

Features & Amenities

Interior Features

Chefs KitchenDouble VanityEat-in KitchenFormal DiningKitchen IslandPrimary BathroomRecessed LightingStorageWasher/Dryer Hookup

Exterior Features

GardenLightingPlaygroundRain Gutters

Property Details

Flooring

HardwoodCombination

Construction

Frame

Pool Features

Pool

Parking

Driveway

Heating

Natural Gas

Cooling

Ductless

Appliances

DishwasherDryerOvenRefrigeratorStainless Steel Appliance(s)Washer

Questions & Answers

This 6-bedroom, 4-bathroom single family at 75 S Penataquit Avenue is listed at $1,549,000 ($428/sqft). The estimated monthly payment is $8,285 based on 20% down, a 30-year loan at 6.5% interest, estimated insurance.

Key features include: Built in 1880, 0.94 acre lot, Private pool, Fireplace. Interior Features: Chefs Kitchen, Double Vanity, Eat-in Kitchen. Exterior Features: Garden, Lighting, Playground.

This property is listed by Maralyn C. Diggin CBR.

MC

Maralyn C. Diggin CBR

Agent at Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Listed by Douglas Elliman Real Estate · Broker phone: 5166812600 · View on Broker Site · Broker website

MLS# 1045401· Source: OneKey MLS· 55 days on PropertySimple

Copyright © 2026 OneKey MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

75 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Open this listing in: