New York

Homes for Sale in Bay Shore

“72 active listings in Bay Shore, New York · Average list price $829,027”

72 listings

Avg $829,027

112 days avg

Search All 72 Homes

Explore

Market Overview

Bay Shore Real Estate at a Glance

Current market statistics for Bay Shore, NY

Active Listings

$829K

Avg Price

$458

Price/Sqft

112

Avg Days

Price Range

From

$34,900

$3,399,000

Property Types

Nearby Cities

Explore homes for sale in cities near Bay Shore, New York

Listing selection

Homes to Explore

Active listings from the bay shore collection

$510K

1761 Manatuck Boulevard

Bay Shore, NY

$500K

1632 N Thompson Drive

Bay Shore, NY

$639K

11 Oakmont Lane

Bay Shore, NY

$599K

1442 Baldwin Boulevard

$650K

54 Oneill Avenue

More listings

Homes for Sale in Bay Shore

Every active listing in Bay Shore, browsable page by page.

Condo

$775K

35 Joyces Way

Bay Shore, NY

2 bd3 ba1,402

Single Family

$680K

1316 Brooklyn Boulevard

Bay Shore, NY

2 bd2 ba1,628

Single Family

$599K

243 Vermont Avenue

Bay Shore, NY

4 bd3 ba1,180

Single Family

$639K

11 Oakmont Lane

Bay Shore, NY

3 bd2 ba1,600

Single Family

$849K

124 Ithaca Street

Bay Shore, NY

4 bd2 ba1,900

Single Family

$699K

1073 Oakneck Road

Bay Shore, NY

3 bd3 ba1,330

Single Family

$700K

116 S Clinton Avenue

Bay Shore, NY

4 bd2 ba1,843

Single Family

$510K

1761 Manatuck Boulevard

Bay Shore, NY

4 bd2 ba1,800

Single Family

$299K

44 Pinebrook Place

Bay Shore, NY

1 bd1 ba0

Single Family

$800K

1624 E 3rd Avenue

Bay Shore, NY

4 bd3 ba2,347

Single Family

$299K

150 Newbrook Lane

Bay Shore, NY

1 bd1 ba0

Single Family

$765K

4 Lee Avenue

Bay Shore, NY

3 bd2 ba1,301

Single Family

$935K

906 Thompson Drive

Bay Shore, NY

5 bd4 ba3,978

Single Family

$620K

1182 E 3rd Avenue

Bay Shore, NY

3 bd1 ba1,075

Single Family

$599K

1442 Baldwin Boulevard

Bay Shore, NY

3 bd2 ba1,532

Single Family

$799K

655 Hyman Avenue

Bay Shore, NY

4 bd3 ba2,200

Single Family

$630K

1327 Brooklyn Boulevard

Bay Shore, NY

3 bd2 ba1,450

Commercial

$2.5M

24 Cottage Avenue

Bay Shore, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Condo

$995K

174 Anchor Lane

Bay Shore, NY

3 bd3 ba2,117

Condo

$210K

1 Hemlock Drive

Bay Shore, NY

1 bd1 ba700

Single Family

$299K

157 Newbrook Lane

Bay Shore, NY

1 bd1 ba0

Single Family

$500K

263 N 3rd Avenue

Bay Shore, NY

2 bd2 ba1,127

Single Family

$629K

1364 5th Avenue

Bay Shore, NY

3 bd1 ba1,050

Single Family

$735K

110 N Park Avenue

Bay Shore, NY

4 bd2 ba1,692

Single Family

$900K

87 Bayway Avenue

Bay Shore, NY

3 bd2 ba1,656

Single Family

$650K

54 Oneill Avenue

Bay Shore, NY

6 bd2 ba2,684

Single Family

$1.5M

75 S Penataquit Avenue

Bay Shore, NY

6 bd4 ba3,617

Single Family

$560K

1556 N Gardiner Drive

Bay Shore, NY

3 bd1 ba1,320

Single Family

$730K

16 West Drive

Bay Shore, NY

5 bd3 ba1,806

Single Family

$690K

7 E Lakeland Street

Bay Shore, NY

4 bd2 ba1,248

Single Family

$829K

893 Gardiner Drive

Bay Shore, NY

5 bd4 ba2,578

Single Family

$829K

893 Gardiner Drive

Bay Shore, NY

5 bd4 ba2,578

Single Family

$600K

1023 Udall Road

Bay Shore, NY

3 bd1 ba1,129

Single Family

$499K

1656 N Thompson Drive

Bay Shore, NY

3 bd1 ba0

Single Family

$525K

1347 Peters Boulevard

Bay Shore, NY

2 bd1 ba856

Single Family

$2.2M

45 S Penataquit Avenue

Bay Shore, NY

10 bd7 ba8,783

Single Family

$600K

19 Chapman Place

Bay Shore, NY

3 bd1 ba1,056

Single Family

$700K

48 Ellen Street

Bay Shore, NY

4 bd2 ba1,176

Land

$200K

Manatuck Boulevard

Bay Shore, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Single Family

$260K

66 Pinebrook Place

Bay Shore, NY

1 bd1 ba782

Single Family

$1.1M

6 Montgomery Lane

Bay Shore, NY

3 bd3 ba2,200

Commercial

$2.4M

193 W Main

Bay Shore, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Single Family

$3.4M

170 S Penataquit Avenue

Bay Shore, NY

3 bd3 ba3,767

Single Family

$495K

1718 N Gardiner Drive

Bay Shore, NY

4 bd1 ba744

Commercial

$425K

300 Brook Avenue

Bay Shore, NY

0 bd0 ba0

Single Family

$669K

182 New York Avenue

Bay Shore, NY

4 bd2 ba2,188

Single Family

$660K

3 Hickory Place

Bay Shore, NY

3 bd2 ba1,986

Single Family

$670K

1431 Brooklyn Boulevard

Bay Shore, NY

4 bd2 ba1,466

Condo

$220K

1 E Hemlock Drive

Bay Shore, NY

1 bd1 ba725

Single Family

$735K

122 Jordan Street

Bay Shore, NY

4 bd2 ba1,258

Showing 1–50 of 72 · Page 1 of 2

Beyond the listings

Continue exploring Bay Shore

Turn the listings into a short list with a clearer read on the Bay Shore market, its neighborhoods, and the home features that matter to you.

Refine Bay Shore search All New York homes

Local market guide

Bay Shore Housing Market

Browse 72 active listings in Bay Shore, New York. The average list price for this active inventory is $829,027. Compare the price and property details reported in each listing.

Average list price $829,027 · Range $34,900–$3,399,000 · 72 active listings

Buyer questions

Frequently Asked Questions

How many active listings are available in Bay Shore, New York?

The current inventory contains 72 active listings in Bay Shore, NY.

What is the average list price in Bay Shore, New York?

The average list price among current active listings in Bay Shore, NY is $829,027. Current list prices range from $34,900 to $3,399,000.

What is the average days on market for active listings in Bay Shore?

Current active listings in Bay Shore, NY report an average of 112 days on market.

What is the average list price per square foot in Bay Shore?

The average list price per square foot among current active listings in Bay Shore, NY is $458.

Shape your search

Browse Bay Shore by home feature

Homes with Solar Features Homes with EV Chargers Homes with Pools Waterfront Homes Homes with Views Homes with Recorded Price Reductions Listings Added to PropertySimple in the Past 7 Days Homes Built Since 2024

Nationwide collections

Explore by listing details

Waterfront ListingsListings Marked Waterfront Listings in Mountain StatesSix-State Collection Multi-Family & Commercial ListingsListings by Property Type Listings with 3+ BedroomsThree or More Bedrooms Listings Priced at $1.5M+Listings by Asking Price Listings Built Since 2015Listings by Year Built

Ready to make the list yours?

Use the full search to set your price, beds, property type, and must-have features for Bay Shore.

Search Bay Shore homes

Homes for Sale in Bay Shore

Bay Shore Real Estate at a Glance

Price Range

Property Types

Nearby Cities

Homes to Explore

More from Bay Shore

1761 Manatuck Boulevard

1632 N Thompson Drive

11 Oakmont Lane

1442 Baldwin Boulevard

54 Oneill Avenue

182 New York Avenue

906 Thompson Drive

9 Dove Lane

Homes for Sale in Bay Shore

35 Joyces Way

1316 Brooklyn Boulevard

243 Vermont Avenue

11 Oakmont Lane

124 Ithaca Street

1073 Oakneck Road

116 S Clinton Avenue

1761 Manatuck Boulevard

44 Pinebrook Place

1624 E 3rd Avenue

150 Newbrook Lane

4 Lee Avenue

906 Thompson Drive

1182 E 3rd Avenue

1442 Baldwin Boulevard

655 Hyman Avenue

1327 Brooklyn Boulevard

24 Cottage Avenue

174 Anchor Lane

1 Hemlock Drive

157 Newbrook Lane

263 N 3rd Avenue

1364 5th Avenue

110 N Park Avenue

87 Bayway Avenue

54 Oneill Avenue

75 S Penataquit Avenue

1556 N Gardiner Drive

16 West Drive

7 E Lakeland Street

893 Gardiner Drive

893 Gardiner Drive

1023 Udall Road

1656 N Thompson Drive

1347 Peters Boulevard

45 S Penataquit Avenue

19 Chapman Place

48 Ellen Street

Manatuck Boulevard

66 Pinebrook Place

6 Montgomery Lane

193 W Main

170 S Penataquit Avenue

1718 N Gardiner Drive

300 Brook Avenue

182 New York Avenue

3 Hickory Place

1431 Brooklyn Boulevard

1 E Hemlock Drive

122 Jordan Street

Bay Shore Housing Market

Frequently Asked Questions

How many active listings are available in Bay Shore, New York?

What is the average list price in Bay Shore, New York?

What is the average days on market for active listings in Bay Shore?

What is the average list price per square foot in Bay Shore?

Browse Bay Shore by home feature

Explore by listing details

Ready to make the list yours?