Homes for Sale in Monticello
“Discover 117 homes in Monticello, Indiana”
Monticello Real Estate at a Glance
Current market statistics for Monticello, IN
117
Active Listings
$353K
Avg Price
$290K
Median Price
$208
Price/Sqft
1,696
Avg Sqft
120
Avg Days
Price Range
From
$59,900
To
$1,199,990
Nearby Cities
Explore homes for sale in cities near Monticello, Indiana
Editor's Picks
Our curated selection of the finest monticello homes
More Monticello Homes
More standout listings from across the Monticello market
$510K
11624 W Briarwood Drive
Monticello, IN
$390K
4386 E Luse Road
Monticello, IN
$322K
110 Brittany Lane
Monticello, IN
$135K
“3 Bedroom Single Family Home in West Monticello, IN - 1,768 Sq Ft Built 1932”
107 DEWEY Street
Monticello, IN
$445K
3222 N State RD 39
Monticello, IN
$410K
10502 N Corley Drive
Monticello, IN
$299K
5660 E 400 N Street
Monticello, IN
$156K
“3-Bedroom Single Family Home on 0.94 Acre Lot in Monticello, IN”
5957 E Redwood Court
Monticello, IN
Homes for Sale in Monticello
Every active listing in Monticello, browsable page by page.
$340K
5599 E Grande Vista Court
Monticello, IN
$290K
3426 N West Shafer Drive
Monticello, IN
$250K
5505 N W Shafer Drive
Monticello, IN
$75K
2 W Fisher Street Extension
Monticello, IN
$400K
8255 N Kiger Drive
Monticello, IN
$369K
12368 N Bridgeview Drive
Monticello, IN
$80K
2410 N West Shafer Drive
Monticello, IN
$110K
“2-Bedroom Single Family Home in Monticello, IN | 993 Sq Ft Built 1943”
400 W Norway Road
Monticello, IN
$280K
10959 N Lower Lake Shore Drive
Monticello, IN
$310K
11758 W Smith Ridge Court
Monticello, IN
$620K
500 E Ohio Street
Monticello, IN
$200K
913 Calley Drive
Monticello, IN
$240K
“Multi-Family Duplex 4 Bedroom 2 Bath 1696 Sq Ft Beattys Western Monticello”
502 Foster Street
Monticello, IN
$230K
504 Foster Street
Monticello, IN
$220K
“4 Bed 2 Bath 1664 Sq Ft Multi-Family Duplex Beattys Western Monticello IN”
506 Foster Street
Monticello, IN
$240K
508 Foster Street
Monticello, IN
$240K
11494 W Paradise Road
Monticello, IN
$510K
11624 W Briarwood Drive
Monticello, IN
$270K
3938 N Becks Place
Monticello, IN
$130K
822 Woodlawn Avenue
Monticello, IN
$260K
9393 N Lenback Court
Monticello, IN
$360K
6335 E Hickory Ridge Court
Monticello, IN
$135K
“3 Bedroom Single Family Home in West Monticello, IN - 1,768 Sq Ft Built 1932”
107 DEWEY Street
Monticello, IN
$220K
31 N Diamond Point Road
Monticello, IN
$248K
535 Twin Lakes Avenue
Monticello, IN
$165K
1016 Jeffrey Avenue
Monticello, IN
$340K
5129 E Shady Point Drive
Monticello, IN
$105K
509 1/2 Walnut Street
Monticello, IN
$329K
4242 N 600 E
Monticello, IN
$380K
808 Terrace Bay Court
Monticello, IN
$310K
523 S Western Loop
Monticello, IN
$210K
1104 Maxwell Avenue
Monticello, IN
$625K
3456 N Shore Acres Court
Monticello, IN
$145K
6079 N Lake Road 67 East Road
Monticello, IN
$240K
705 Bluewater Drive
Monticello, IN
$350K
6855 N Skaggs Court
Monticello, IN
$500K
8395 N Kiger Drive
Monticello, IN
$200K
214 W Washington Street
Monticello, IN
$495K
2951 N Lakeshore Drive
Monticello, IN
$290K
5010 E 500 N
Monticello, IN
$250K
6035 N Hodges Drive
Monticello, IN
$599K
10922 N Lower Lake Shore Drive
Monticello, IN
$450K
1828 N Royal Oaks Drive
Monticello, IN
$500K
10078 N 1200 W
Monticello, IN
$240K
2055 Deepwater (Lot 15) Loop
Monticello, IN
$230K
2079 Deepwater (Lot 11) Loop
Monticello, IN
$65K
2049 Deepwater (Lot 16) Loop
Monticello, IN
$65K
2043 Deepwater (Lot 17) Loop
Monticello, IN
$225K
“Monticello IN 5 Bedroom Multi-Family 3 Bath 2133 Sq Ft Two Unit Home”
318 S Illinois Street
Monticello, IN
$240K
2061 Deepwater (Lot 14) Loop
Monticello, IN
Showing 1–50 of 117 · Page 1 of 3
Continue exploring Monticello
Turn the listings into a short list with a clearer read on the Monticello market, its neighborhoods, and the home features that matter to you.
Monticello Housing Market
Monticello, Indiana offers a small-town setting that appeals to those looking for a more relaxed lifestyle away from larger urban centers. Many who relocate here include families and individuals interested in proximity to lakes and natural surroundings. The character varies by neighborhood, providing options from established residential areas to newer developments. Lifestyle includes opportunities for outdoor recreation such as boating and hiking in local parks, along with a selection of dining establishments that cater to everyday needs.
Read the full market guide
The community is served by the local public school district and nearby private options, supporting education for residents with children. The region experiences four distinct seasons, with warm summers and cold winters typical of the Midwest. In the current market, there are 117 active listings with an average price of $352,556 and a median price of $289,900. Homes range from $59,900 to $1,199,990 and average 1,696 square feet, with properties typically remaining on the market for around 120 days. This mix of housing options supports buyers seeking both modest and larger properties in a setting that balances everyday convenience with access to the outdoors.
Median list price $289,900 · Range $59,900–$1,199,990 · 117 active listings
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the average home price in Monticello Indiana?
How long do homes stay on the market in Monticello?
What schools are available for families in Monticello?
What is the typical home size in Monticello Indiana?
What lifestyle and amenities does Monticello offer residents?
Shape your search
Browse Monticello by home feature
Ready to make the list yours?
Use the full search to set your price, beds, property type, and must-have features for Monticello.